Nassau County’s Best Tasting Gyro

Craving an authentic Greek Gyro? Just go to Gyro Jimmy's.

Order Online
View Full Menu
  • Mon–Sun: 11:30am–8:30pm
Highly Rated on Yelp
Loved across Carle Place
4.8★ Star
Over 450+ Guest Reviews
Made From Scratch
Authentic Homemade Recipes
Carle Place, NY
Traditional Greek Experince

What We Serve

All the Gyro's. All the ways.

Fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and Greek favorites made just the way you like them. Jimmy knows his gyros.

Appetizers

Fresh & tasty →

Plates

Hearty & satisfying →

Sandwich

Loaded & Delicious →

Souvlaki Sticks

Flame grilled →

Meat Only

Tender & Flavorful →
View full menu
about gyro jimmy

Our Story

Gyro Jimmy's is the best homemade gyro around.

Gyro Jimmy prides itself on its authentic homemade greek gyro. Using only the best ingredients, Gyro Jimmy's offers a traditional Greek experience conveniently located in the heart of Carle Place. You can dine in or take it to go a quick lunch time meal or dinner for the whole family.

More About US

What you get

Step Inside Gyro Jimmy's, Carle Place

gyro jimmys catering service

Catering

Make Your Next Event Delicious with Gyro Jimmy’s Catering

Planning a party, corporate gathering, family celebration, or special event? Let Gyro Jimmy’s take care of the food.
  • Freshly prepared flavorful, herb-tossed and spice-infused dishes
  • Same-day orders may be accommodated when possible
  • Catering options for events of all kinds
  • We recommend placing your order at least 24 hours in advance to help ensure your preferred serving time
View Catering menu

What Guests Say

5 Stars - Every Time

★★★★★
"This place is an absolute hidden gem! From the moment you walk in the staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming. I came in during the afternoon and was blown away by their menu they have fantastic lunch specials..."

YELP REVIEW

★★★★★
"What a nice local place!! Very tasty food, super friendly staff fast and all together pleasant. While we were waiting for our food, food for delivery was going out non-stop. That is a definite sign of this place being loved by locals..."

GOOGLE REVIEW

★★★★★
"Just had lunch at Gyro Jimmys! The food was amazing. I loved my moussaka! The service was wonderful. They really took the time to talk and made great recommendations! Will definitely be going back!"

FACEBOOK REVIEW

★★★★★
"This place is amazing! I got the traditional gyro plate with cucumber and tomato salad and the Greek fries. Let me tell you…some of the best gyro meat I’ve eaten. The salad was fresh and a perfect compliment to the gyro..."

GOOGLE REVIEW

★★★★★
"Authentic Greek Cuisine, pricing cost is similar to Wendy's & McDonalds yet all the food is homemade, prepared fresh, with the best quality ingredients for an extremely affordable price. If you've yet to have the pleasure of ordering..."

FACEBOOK REVIEW

★★★★★
"This was such a pleasant experience. Ordering via the website for pickup was easy. I got a lunch special of sandwich + fries. The food was ready when I arrive, fresh & hot. The store itself was *immaculately* clean..."

YELP REVIEW
Get in Touch

Visit Gyro Jimmy's

Questions, big plans or big appetites? Let's talk.